We Polled Our Editors for Their Under-$25 Must-Haves, and They’re All on Sale Ahead of October Prime Day

Amazon has just unveiled its Prime Day 2025, set for October 7, but if you’re not keen on waiting that long, there’s a plethora of early-bird deals to snag right away. We’ve curated a selection of our top picks that are currently discounted from brands such as L’Oreal, Maybelline, and Kitsch. These editor-endorsed items include cozy throw blankets, comfortable lounge ensembles, makeup, leave-in conditioners, fragrance, and more, all priced under $25 on Amazon.

Here are some of the highlights:

– Bedsure GentleSoft Throw Blanket, now $13 instead of $16

– Trendy Queen Turtleneck Long-Sleeve Shirt, now $15 instead of $18

Cliganic Organic Jojoba Oil, Portable Travel Mini Jewelry Box, RONXS Candle Lighter and ANRABESS Two Piece Outfit
Cliganic Organic Jojoba Oil, Portable Travel Mini Jewelry Box, RONXS Candle Lighter and ANRABESS Two Piece Outfit

– Cliganic Organic Jojoba Oil, now $10 instead of $14

– Sun Bum Revitalizing 3-in-1 Leave-In Conditioner, now $16 instead of $17

– L’Oreal Paris Infallible 32 Hour Fresh Wear Foundation, now $15 instead of $17

– Neveika Portable Jewelry Box, now $7 instead of $8

– Lillusory 2-Piece Sweat Shorts Set, starting at $20 instead of $28

– DiDiSky Under-Cabinet Motion-Sensor Lights, now $13 instead of $20

– Kitsch Hair Perfume, now $17 instead of $20

– Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Color-Correcting Concealer, now $10 instead of $11

– Ronxs Electric Candle Lighter, now $8 instead of $13

Here are some insights from our team:

“This Bedsure throw might just be the softest thing you’ve ever felt. It’s warmth is perfect for movie nights or as an extra layer on your bed. I adore it for being lightweight and easy to wash. The texture stays fluffy and doesn’t get pilly or rough with use, and it doesn’t shed. At just $13, it’s a steal and an ideal housewarming present!” – Euna Park, Senior Shopping Editor

“I’m a big fan of turtlenecks for the cold months because they’re so adaptable for layering or standalone wear. This one comes in 20 stunning colors, and under $20, you can grab a few. The material is stretchy and comfortable, and you won’t get too warm if you wear it under a sweater.” – Gabriela Garcia, Strategy Editor

“I’ve been using this jojoba oil for over a year on my cuticles and hands, and it’s left them incredibly soft. One bottle lasts for months, and it’s great as a post-shower body moisturizer. Plus, a little goes a long way, and it dries quickly, leaving no greasy residue.” – Emma Ashe, Shopping Editor

“I’ve been loyal to this leave-in conditioner for years. It smells fantastic, like bananas and coconut, and makes my dry, bleached hair manageable. I usually opt for the 4-ounce spray, which lasts about two months, but the 1.5-ounce size is perfect for travel due to its compact size. My partner uses it too, so we only need to pack one bottle for trips.” – Meg Lappe, Senior Editorial Director

“This foundation does wonders for masking the redness in my face. The best part is that I don’t need much—a little goes a long way. It’s my go-to makeup, paired with some powder, and I often forget I’m wearing it because it’s so light and doesn’t crease.” – Allison Cacich, Editorial Director

“I received this travel jewelry case as a gift and now never travel without it. It keeps my jewelry organized and tangle-free, as opposed to throwing everything into a drawstring pouch.” – Lily Gray, Senior Shopping Editor

“These lounge sets are my summer staple, and while I’m sad to put them away, this is a great autumn alternative. They come in many cute colors to match your mood—I have one in dark gray that I wear weekly.” – Mia Ingui, Editor

“These motion-sensor lights are a game-changer in my closets with poor lighting. They turn on automatically when I open the door, and I’m considering one for the laundry room too. Plus, they’re USB rechargeable, which is ideal since I’m not about to mess with electrical installations.” – Steph Osmanski, Shopping Writer

“I’m a perfume enthusiast and love trying new scents. I just finished my Kitsch hair perfume in the Amber Shores scent and am eager to restock, especially at the sale price of $17. It serves as both a body and hair mist, with the scent lasting all day. The 1.7-ounce size is perfect for on-the-go use.” – Gabriella Maestri, Shopping Writer

“Pregnancy has caused my acne to flare up, and while I can’t control the hormonal breakouts, I can cover them with this green-tinted concealer. It neutralizes redness and allows me to apply a lighter concealer on top. It’s also great for shading mixing to achieve a better foundation match in seconds.” – Wendy Vazquez, Senior Shopping Writer

“My best friend introduced me to USB lighters, and they’ve revolutionized my candle-lighting experience. This flameless, electric lighter is a breeze to use and the fact that it’s rechargeable is a significant plus. At $8, it’s a no-brainer.” – Carly Totten, Shopping Editor

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *